Best Robo-Advisors 2026: Betterment vs Wealthfront vs Schwab

What Are Robo-Advisors?

Robo-advisors are automated investment platforms that build and manage diversified portfolios for you. They use algorithms to select investments, rebalance your portfolio, and implement tax strategies, all without human intervention.

How Robo-Advisors Work

1. Risk Assessment: You answer questions about goals, timeline, and risk tolerance
2. Portfolio Construction: Algorithm selects appropriate mix of ETFs
3. Automatic Investment: Deposits are invested according to target allocation
4. Rebalancing: Portfolio is automatically adjusted when it drifts
5. Tax Optimization: Tax-loss harvesting captures losses to offset gains

Typical Robo Portfolio

Asset Class	Conservative	Moderate	Aggressive
US Stocks	20%	40%	55%
International Stocks	10%	20%	30%
US Bonds	45%	25%	10%
International Bonds	15%	10%	0%
Real Estate (REITs)	5%	3%	3%
Commodities	5%	2%	2%

Typical Fee Structure

Most robo-advisors charge 0.25% annually. On a $100,000 portfolio, that's $250 per year. You also pay the underlying ETF expense ratios (typically 0.05-0.15%).

Major Robo-Advisors Compared

Robo-Advisor	Management Fee	Minimum	Key Feature
Betterment	0.25%	$0	Best all-around features
Wealthfront	0.25%	$500	Best for tax optimization
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios	0% (free)	$5,000	No advisory fee
Vanguard Digital Advisor	0.25%	$3,000	Vanguard funds only
Fidelity Go	0.35%	$10	Fidelity integration
SoFi Automated Investing	0%	$1	Free, basic features

Assets Under Management

Robo-Advisor	AUM (2026)	Founded
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios	$80+ billion	2015
Betterment	$45+ billion	2010
Wealthfront	$55+ billion	2011
Vanguard Digital Advisor	$25+ billion	2020

Betterment Deep Dive

Betterment is the original robo-advisor, launching in 2010. It remains one of the most feature-rich options available.

Betterment Pricing

Plan	Fee	Minimum	Features
Digital	0.25%	$0	Core robo features
Premium	0.40%	$100,000	Unlimited CFP access

Betterment Features

• Tax-Loss Harvesting: Daily monitoring for tax savings
• Tax-Coordinated Portfolio: Places assets in optimal account types
• Goal-Based Investing: Separate buckets for different goals
• Socially Responsible Options: ESG portfolios available
• Crypto Portfolios: Up to 5% crypto allocation
• Flexible Portfolios: Some customization allowed
• Cash Reserve: High-yield savings (4.50% APY)
• Checking Account: With debit card

Betterment Portfolio Options

Portfolio Type	Description
Core	Classic stock/bond mix using low-cost ETFs
Socially Responsible	ESG-focused funds
Goldman Sachs Smart Beta	Factor-based investing
BlackRock Target Income	Income-focused for retirees
Innovative Technology	Tech-heavy allocation
Crypto	Stocks + Bitcoin/Ethereum exposure

Betterment Pros & Cons

Pros:

• No account minimum
• Excellent tax optimization
• Goal-based approach is intuitive
• High-yield cash account
• Access to CFPs with Premium

Cons:

• 0.25% fee adds up on large accounts
• No direct indexing (unlike Wealthfront)
• Limited portfolio customization
• Premium tier expensive at 0.40%

Wealthfront Deep Dive

Wealthfront has emerged as the leader in tax optimization, particularly with their direct indexing feature.

Wealthfront Pricing

Feature	Fee	Minimum
Automated Investing	0.25%	$500
Direct Indexing (US)	0.25%	$100,000
Direct Indexing (US + Intl)	0.25%	$500,000
Bond ETFs	0.25%	Included

Wealthfront Features

• Tax-Loss Harvesting: Industry-leading implementation
• Direct Indexing: Buy individual stocks instead of ETFs for more tax alpha
• Risk Parity: Alternative to traditional stock/bond mix
• Smart Beta: Factor-tilted portfolios
• Self-Driving Money: Automatic bill pay and savings
• Portfolio Line of Credit: Borrow against portfolio at low rates
• Cash Account: 5.0% APY on cash
• 529 Plans: College savings integration

Direct Indexing Advantage

Direct indexing is Wealthfront's killer feature. Instead of buying VTI (total stock market ETF), Wealthfront buys 500+ individual stocks directly. Benefits:

• Enhanced Tax-Loss Harvesting: Harvest losses in individual stocks while maintaining market exposure
• More Opportunities: 500 stocks = 500 chances to harvest losses
• Tax Alpha: Can add 1-2% annually through tax savings
• Customization: Exclude specific stocks or sectors

Wealthfront claims direct indexing can add 1.8% annually after taxes for high earners in their first year, declining over time.

Wealthfront Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Best-in-class tax optimization
• Direct indexing at $100K (others require $500K+)
• 5% APY on cash
• Portfolio line of credit
• Excellent mobile app

Cons:

• $500 minimum to start
• No human advisor access
• Limited portfolio customization below direct indexing
• No fractional shares in regular accounts

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios

Schwab's robo-advisor is unique: $0 advisory fee. But there's a catch.

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Pricing

Service	Fee	Minimum
Intelligent Portfolios (robo only)	$0	$5,000
Intelligent Portfolios Premium	$30/month after $300 one-time fee	$25,000

The Cash Allocation "Fee"

Schwab doesn't charge an advisory fee, but requires a significant cash allocation (6-10% of your portfolio). This cash earns low interest (0.45%), while Schwab uses it for banking operations.

The opportunity cost:

Portfolio Size	Cash @ 8%	Lost Returns (5% market)	Effective Fee
$50,000	$4,000	$200/year	0.40%
$100,000	$8,000	$400/year	0.40%
$500,000	$40,000	$2,000/year	0.40%

That 0.40% effective fee is higher than Betterment's 0.25%. "Free" isn't always cheaper.

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Features

• Schwab ETFs: Uses low-cost Schwab-branded ETFs
• Tax-Loss Harvesting: Available for accounts $50,000+
• Automatic Rebalancing: Keeps portfolio on target
• Goal Tracking: Basic goal-based features
• 24/7 Customer Service: Schwab's excellent support
• Premium Option: Unlimited CFP access for $30/month

Schwab Pros & Cons

Pros:

• No explicit advisory fee
• Backed by Schwab (trusted institution)
• Access to Schwab's full ecosystem
• Premium tier is reasonable for CFP access
• Tax-loss harvesting included

Cons:

• High cash drag effectively costs 0.40%
• $5,000 minimum is higher than Betterment
• Less customization than competitors
• No direct indexing

Tax-Loss Harvesting Explained

Tax-loss harvesting is a key benefit of robo-advisors. Here's how it works:

The Process

1. You own ETF that drops in value (loss position)
2. Robo sells the ETF, realizing the loss
3. Robo immediately buys similar (not identical) ETF
4. You maintain market exposure while capturing tax loss
5. Loss offsets gains elsewhere, reducing taxes

Example

Step	Action	Tax Impact
1	Buy VTI at $200	-
2	VTI drops to $180 (10% loss)	-
3	Sell VTI, realize $20 loss	$20 loss captured
4	Buy ITOT at $180 (similar fund)	Maintain exposure
5	Use $20 loss to offset $20 gain elsewhere	Save $4.40 in taxes (22% bracket)

Tax-Loss Harvesting Value

Tax Bracket	Value of $10,000 Harvested Loss
22%	$2,200 in tax savings
32%	$3,200 in tax savings
37%	$3,700 in tax savings

Robo Tax-Loss Harvesting Comparison

Feature	Betterment	Wealthfront	Schwab
TLH Available	Yes	Yes	Yes ($50K+)
Minimum for TLH	$0	$500	$50,000
Frequency	Daily	Daily	Daily
Direct Indexing	No	Yes ($100K+)	No

Direct Indexing Revolution

Direct indexing is transforming robo-advising. Instead of buying index ETFs, you own the underlying stocks directly.

How Direct Indexing Works

1. Robo buys 200-500 individual stocks to replicate index
2. Each stock is a separate tax lot
3. When individual stocks drop, robo harvests those losses
4. Replaces with similar stocks to maintain exposure
5. Net result: Same returns, more tax losses captured

Direct Indexing Availability

Provider	Minimum	Fee	Stocks Held
Wealthfront	$100,000	0.25%	500+
Betterment	Not available	-	-
Schwab	$250,000	Custom pricing	Varies
Fidelity	$5,000	0.40%	Varies
Vanguard Personal	$500,000	0.30-0.50%	Varies

Direct Indexing Benefits

• Enhanced TLH: 500 stocks = 500 opportunities to harvest
• Customization: Exclude specific companies (competitors, ethical concerns)
• Factor Tilts: Overweight value, momentum, or other factors
• ESG Screening: Remove fossil fuels, weapons, etc.
• Concentrated Stock: Build around existing large positions

Who Benefits Most

Investor Profile	Direct Indexing Value
High income, taxable account	High (more tax to offset)
IRA only	None (no TLH in IRAs)
New investor	Moderate (fewer gains to offset)
Long-term holder	Declining (fewer harvesting opportunities)
Active seller	High (losses offset gains)

Robo vs DIY: When to Use Each

Choose a Robo-Advisor If:

• You want completely hands-off investing
• You value automatic tax-loss harvesting
• You don't want to learn about asset allocation
• You'd otherwise not invest consistently
• You have taxable accounts benefiting from TLH
• You want goal-based features and tracking
• You prefer an "out of sight, out of mind" approach

Choose DIY If:

• You want zero management fees
• You're comfortable building a simple portfolio
• Most of your money is in tax-advantaged accounts (IRA, 401k)
• You enjoy managing your own investments
• You want maximum control over asset allocation
• You're willing to rebalance manually once per year

DIY Alternative: Three-Fund Portfolio

A simple DIY portfolio that rivals any robo:

Fund	Ticker	Expense Ratio	Allocation
US Total Market	VTI or FZROX	0.03% or 0%	60%
International	VXUS or FZILX	0.07% or 0%	25%
Total Bond	BND or FXNAX	0.03% or 0.025%	15%

Total cost: Under 0.05% annually. No advisory fee.

Cost Comparison: Robo vs DIY

Portfolio Size	Robo Fee (0.25%)	DIY ETF Cost (~0.05%)	Annual Savings DIY
$25,000	$62.50	$12.50	$50
$100,000	$250	$50	$200
$500,000	$1,250	$250	$1,000
$1,000,000	$2,500	$500	$2,000

Hidden Costs to Watch

Cash Drag (Schwab)

As discussed, Schwab's 8% cash allocation costs more than explicit 0.25% fees at Betterment or Wealthfront.

Fund Expense Ratios

You pay the robo fee PLUS underlying ETF expenses. Always check what funds the robo uses.

Tax Costs of Leaving

If you switch robo-advisors or go DIY, selling positions may trigger capital gains. Direct indexing makes this worse (500 positions to sell).

Opportunity Cost

For IRA accounts, tax-loss harvesting provides no benefit. The 0.25% fee is pure cost with no tax offset.

Which Robo-Advisor to Choose

Best Overall: Wealthfront

For taxable accounts, Wealthfront's direct indexing at $100,000 provides unmatched tax alpha. The 0.25% fee can be more than offset by tax savings.

Best for Beginners: Betterment

No minimum, excellent goal-based features, and intuitive interface make Betterment perfect for getting started.

Best for Schwab Loyalists: Schwab Intelligent Portfolios

If you're already in the Schwab ecosystem and want everything under one roof, the "free" option works despite cash drag.

Best Value: DIY at Fidelity or Vanguard

If you're willing to spend 30 minutes per year rebalancing, you can build an equivalent portfolio for nearly free.

My Recommendation by Scenario

Scenario	Recommendation
Under $25K, want hands-off	Betterment
$100K+ taxable, high income	Wealthfront (direct indexing)
IRA only	DIY (no TLH benefit)
Want human advisor access	Schwab Premium or Betterment Premium
Already at Fidelity/Vanguard	DIY three-fund portfolio
Want free at any cost	Schwab (accept cash drag)

---

Robo-advisor features and pricing change frequently. Verify current offerings directly with each provider before opening an account. This comparison is accurate as of January 2026.